The Koreas | Society | East Asia

This Is South Korea’s K-pop Soft Power Moment

K-pop offers something different to the nationalism projected by China and the territorial politics of exclusion. 

This Is South Korea’s K-pop Soft Power Moment

K-pop group Twice pose for the photographers during a showcase for the 8th mini album “Feel Special” in Seoul, South Korea, Monday, September 23, 2019.

Credit: AP Photo/Lee Jin-man
that China kicked off in 2013. While the Chinese project is impressive, it will eventually fall to the politics of and nationalism that historically have divided Asia. The most effective influence project of Asia, and the globe, might actually be K-pop with true cultural attraction coming from pop stars and their fandoms.

K-pop is a global expression of , fueled by the , the “Korean wave,” that has sought to since the late 1990s. The is part of a Korean overhaul of the arts and entertainment sectors to explicitly . In the same year that BTS reached the summit of the Billboard Hot 100, Bong Joon-ho’s “” won the 2020 Oscar for best picture and K-pop girl groups (reaching eighth) and cracked the for the first time. 

These trends are only the beginning. is a force to be reckoned with. As a result, South Korea is challenging not only the cultural ascendancy the United States maintains, but the course for the future of Asia. Prices of art have sky-rocketed. model-turned-actress HoYeon Jung is the first person from Asia to grace of American Vogue in its 130-year history after the show dominated Netflix. As of 2021, Korean content even U.S.-produced content for streaming viewers in the East Asian region. In 2022, Disney+ secured the rights to stream Korean content, including a and , in support of its expansion into Asia. 

K-pop offers something different to the nationalism projected by China and the territorial politics of exclusion. Instead of national identity creating fault lines, in K-pop, divergent national representation presents an opportunity for culture and economic dominance through collectivization of artistic expression. Many K-pop songs literally are a cultural mashup of languages, visual styles, and dance all shepherded by South Korean production values and .

The K-pop’n Road 

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

As scholars of and the , we watch with interest as the distribution of cultural power shifts in the music industry. K-pop is more than the ideal of a or band that has been the foundation of the music industry since its . Vox’s notes that K-pop is “Korean music that blends pop, hip-hop, and dance” yet the idea of the musical style being “Korean” specifically is declining gradually. Like “Hollywood” being used as a term for the movie industry, the “Korean” in K-pop denotes the start but not the evolution of the art form. 

K-pop’s expansion north to Russia, east to the United States, west to India, and south to Oceania demonstrates that its global domination is only beginning. The tentacles of Korean cultural attraction, the literal definition of soft power, extend globally, infecting the minds of a new generation no longer concerned with the politics of their elders. The infectious positivity common in K-pop can trump even nationalism (“” represents an outlier).    

The big in K-pop 212; SM Entertainment, JYP Entertainment, and YG Entertainment — were in the second half of the nineties, inspired by the Japanese Idol system. The big three were later joined by Big Hit Entertainment — recently rebranded as HYBE Corporation — founded by former JYP employee Bang Si-hyuk in 2005 who struck gold thanks to the massive success of BTS.

to South Korea’s leading position in digital technologies. The power of social media in the emerging information age facilitates fanatical devotion to artists and their careers. These artists penetrate trending pages, and dominate on , and HYBE-owned . Artists use social media — especially video platforms — to amplify messages and create indelible images. Their efforts are complemented by the fans, who often act as highly professional marketeers for their bands on social media.

K-Pop moves in , as do most cultural movements. YG’s Psy’s novelty hit “” might have been a distraction, but in reality, it was more of a herald of the coming arrival of YG’s Blackpink and BTS, which represent the new generation of K-pop. While all the members of BTS are Korean, out of the four Blackpink members, there is one Thai member, , with spending a part of her youth in New Zealand and being the child of Korean immigrants in Australia. Blackpink’s producer and main songwriter, is a hip-hop artist from Diamond Bar, an affluent Southern California suburb. 

Diversification of newly debuting artists is the norm now in K-pop. The current fourth generation is known as the “” with many of the stars coming from outside South Korea and aiming for international success from the start. The majority of bands have front-facing English names and incorporate multiple languages in each song, if not in the same lyric, expanding global reach and audience.

Cultural Confrontation

It will be interesting to witness the evolution of the Korean K-pop’n Road, especially in relation to China. K-pop is one of the first true forms of soft power, like and the industry before it, that can have a real impact on international relations. It can form an approximation of hard power through music and activism that is more powerful than any missile system that Korea could develop. 

Confrontation seemed to be an early theme. To “celebrate” the birthday of Kim Jong Un in 2016 K-pop was “ from loudspeakers setup on the border.” Also in 2016, girl group had to apologize when Taiwanese member Tzuyu waved a Taiwanese flag. Her apology stated “there is only one China.” At the time JYP noted that it would overhaul its strategy of Hallyu to be less

Compare this apology to the 2020 incident where BTS was of disrespecting Chinese soldiers through omission during an for an award given on the 70th Anniversary of the Korean War. Leader of BTS’ RM that “we will always remember the history of pain that our two nations [the United States and Korea] shared together and the sacrifices of countless men and women,” and did not refer to China’s struggle during the Korean War. As reported at the time, the offensive only lasted two days. China’s deleted some attacks on BTS after push back from the fandom. The BTS Army beat China at the time.

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

While social media in China used to fill up with K-pop content, the tide somewhat after the South Korean government deployed the THAAD missile defense system in 2017. In reaction, the Chinese government concerts, tours, and overall exposure to K-pop. More recently, the Cyberspace Administration of China has additional measures to curb “” which it says “distorts minors’ values and endangers social governance.” China instituted to , outlawing bulk purchase of albums and “.” 

The message is clear: K-pop idol worshiping is no longer tolerated in China. Yet the future is uncertain. International is the key for the industry, suggesting that the attraction of K-pop power will . There is a that the country has never invaded another country; while inaccurate the basic premise is true and continues to this day. Instead of a military invasion the K-pop cultural invasion continues despite intervention from China.

The Value of K-pop

is really about the power of attraction as a method of influence. It is a coercive process made through non-military means. Real soft power is comprehensive, it encourages cultural immersion and adaptation. It can be positive, providing a critical counter-narrative at a moment of increased racism and violence directed at of Asian descent around the globe due to fears of COVID-19. 

The general image of K-pop, , accusations of “,” and fans, is wholesome and winsome. K-pop provides representation and inspiration. BTS was invited to visit the United Nations General Assembly in 2021, this time as appointed special envoy of South Korea, to their belief in future generations. When three band members tested positive for COVID-19 later that year, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the director-general of the World Health Organization wished them a speedy recovery on , alongside a reminder about precautionary measures and the importance of vaccinations. An found that BTS fandom was a prime driver of positive information about protection from the virus.

The power of K-pop is in the fandom. This fandom develops global reach and now seeks to influence daily life, including the Black Lives Matter protests. In 2020, a Donald Trump rally in Oklahoma was when the BTS Army snatched up tickets online to embarrass the politician. Overall, the message was hopeful, with the noting that the generally apolitical K-pop fans “may lend itself to more radical gestures, especially in a time of increased political polarization.” 

The Korean expression “!” does not represent the typical Western conception of confrontation. Instead in Korean it generally means good luck, or “you can do it!” It’s a positive expression of collective unity against a challenge. This is the central ethos of K-pop: meet a challenge through positive force. This is also the hope of K-pop as an alternative to the destructive politics of confrontation typical in international politics.